- Shaheen Javed Bhatti
We need to activate ‘Green Peace’ on pollution in India with consequences on Pakistan.Pakistan media to pick up campaign by incorporating comments of local masses in Lahore/ Punjab on problems created by SMOG.Since the start of the year, air pollution in major cities in India and Pakistan has reached levels well beyond what is considered hazardous to human health.On 2 January, the air pollution in Lahore reached 591 on the US Air Quality Index (US AQI)-almost double the level, 300, considered to be “hazardous” by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).The pollution is so bad in the northern Pakistan city that it has affected the power supply in the region, with power plants closing due to the heavy smog, leaving many communities without electricity.On 3 January, the US AQI in Delhi, India’s capital, reached 581, according to data from consumer air monitoring network AirVisual. Levels of PM2.5-fine particules that penetrate deep into the lungs-reached about 12 times the level considered safe by the US government, with visibility poor.Delhi’s pollution is often officially blamed on the traffic congestion, but the city is surrounded by 14 gigawatts of coal-fired power stations and heavy industry, noted Lauri Myllyvirta?, lead analyst, global air pollution unit for environmental group Greenpeace. Windblown dust is another major contributor.Lahore is fringed by two major industrial hotspots and an oil-fired power plant, which were flagged as emissions hotspots by Greenpeace’s nitrogen dioxide satellite-based analysis late last year. Both cities are affected by crop-burning and household fuel burning in the Punjab region in the cold winter months.While the pollution in Lahore and Delhi is particularly severe now, the problem is not exclusive to these cities. Air pollution reached hazardous levels in the Bangladesh capital Dhaka and the former Indian capital Kolkata on 4 January.”What we should really be talking about is pollution in the entire Indo-Gangetic plain all the way from Lahore to Dhaka, where around 800 million people live,” said Myllyvirta?. The Indo-Gangetic plain is a large valley with relatively little wind for much of the year to disperse pollutants. Air quality monitor providers] didn’t realise the insane crazy poison soup in North India, Pakistan, Bangladesh and Mongolia could see the index shoot above 1000. So now 999 has become the new ‘crazy bad’. Lauri Myllyvirta?, lead analyst, global air pollution unit, Greenpeace.The US AQI measures five key pollutants and categorises them in bands; 0-50 is considered “good”, 151-200 is “unhealthy” and 301-500 is deemed “hazardous”-anyone experiencing it may suffer health impacts and should avoid any strenuous activity outdoors. The scale does not officially go above 500, because the EPA did not figure pollution would ever reach such high levels. Super-severe air pollution was given the term “crazy bad” by a US Embassy official in 2010, when AQI readings in Beijing eclipsed 500. The embassy later revised the term to “beyond index” and netizens in China dubbed 500+ readings as “broke the index”. The World Health Organisation deems air quality scores above 500 to be more than 20 times the level of particulate matter in the air that can be considered safe for people to breathe. Readings went off the US AQI charts again in 2013, when pollution in the Chinese capital reached a “post-apocalyptic” 755. Beijing’s air has markedly improved since as a result of a government anti-pollution plan hatched in 2013, although it reached “hazardous” levels on 2 January, according to AirVisual data. Online air quality data providers such as AirVisual extended the US AQI to indicate levels higher than 500, but did not design the air quality pins on their maps to display four digit numbers. “They didn’t realise the insane crazy poison soup in North India, Pakistan, Bangladesh and some other places like Ulan Baatar [the Mongolian capital] could see the index shoot up above 1000,” noted Myllyvirta?. “So now 999 has become the new ‘crazy bad’/’broke the index'”. Shifting to cleaner energy sources in power generation, industry and households, setting higher emissions standards for factories and vehicles, farming methods that avoid stubble burning and improving how waste is managed are the best ways to tackle air pollution in South Asia, Myllyvirta? said.”What’s key is to implement these measures on the regional level and not just in a few cities-most of the headline-grabbing pollution in these cities originates outside of the city limits,” he said, adding that the causes of air pollution need to be addressed together and not in isolation-otherwise any solution will fail. India launched a programme to address air pollution last year, a long-awaited response to the country eclipsing China as the world’s most polluted. But the National Clean Air Programme (NCAP) has been widely criticised for its weak implementation and enforcement. At least one in eight deaths in India can be attributed to air pollution, which kills more people than tobacco, according to a national study released last month.As India’s north continues to struggle with extreme pollution levels, the story has put a fresh spotlight on air quality in cities across Asia. Beijing has long been notorious for its smog – but statistics show that India, Pakistan and Bangladesh have worse air by far. Of the world’s most polluted 30 cities, 22 are in India, according to research by IQ AirVisual, a Swiss-based group that gathers air-quality data globally, and Greenpeace. The remaining eight cities are all in Pakistan, Bangladesh and China – but the list doesn’t include Beijing, which comes in at number 122. Looking at overall countries, it’s Bangladesh that has the worst air, followed by Pakistan and then India. As these countries have very different densities of measuring stations and transparency of data, the statistics have to be read with a degree of caution. But they certainly indicate an overall trend. Pollution in urban areas is usually a mix of different factors – mostly traffic, fossil fuel burning power plants and heavy industries. What differentiates China from India is that in the latter, there is still a lot of burning of agricultural stubble when farmers want to clear their fields. The burning usually takes place in autumn. “In this episode, the big problem really seems to have been the agricultural burning,” assistant professor Thomas Smith of the London School of Economics told . “That’s one thing that China has tackled. All agricultural burning has been banned, full stop.” A global overview for fires and thermal abnormalities is made available by Nasa, and allows users to track developments over past days and weeks. The area north-west of Delhi shows a highly unusual concentration of fires, Prof Smith points out. “And you can’t underestimate how important agricultural burning is – even though people often think only of cars and heavy industry as the causes.” In the wake of the pollution spike, India’s Supreme Court ordered a stop to stubble burning in the states around Delhi. But the city’s situation is made worse by the colder winter air which is more stagnant, trapping the pollutants in place. Prof Smith also points out that “while India is largely reactive, Beijing tends to be more proactive and preventative to try to stop the problems from happening in the first place”.
The author is SVP Environmental watch trust Pakistan.
